BA on Assignment

May 12, 2012

Starter Cartridges

More articles for »
Written for: Communicado Magazine
Tags: , , , , ,
printer cartridges

I recently decided to upgrade to a wireless printer at home. My previous printer was an HP and I’ve had great success with it, so, I decided to buy another one. I bought it, went through the agony of getting it set up wirelessly and after two hours on the phone with HP support, even got the scanner working. Whew…

Now I’m ready to print with ease. Not so fast….

On three different occasions, I printed items of about 10 pages each and the black printer cartridge ran out. I thought that was odd, so, I called HP to say, “I think I got a defective printer cartridge.” I did not get a defective printer cartridge… Here’s what HP told me…

In today’s personal printer industry, it’s common practice to use starter cartridges. Starter means, you get enough ink in the cartridge to get the machine up and running and then you’re on your own. Is this not a beautiful marketing ploy to generate individual printer cartridge sales? I think I meant to say manipulate…

This was news to me, so, I decided to put this industry standard to the test. I called two of HP’s biggest competitors – Lexmark and Canon.

Lexmark confirmed for me that they use starter cartridges in their personal printers. It took a few minutes to get them to admit it, but, they eventually did with no conditions.

My next phone call was to Canon. Canon said, for their personal printers – the smaller ones – they do not use starter cartridges. However, for their commercial printers – the larger ones – they do use starter cartridges just because of their size.

So, the practice is not an industry standard, but, an individual corporate decision. But, more than the answer to the exact question I put in front of each company is the general reception I faced from each company…

HP and Lexmark were a bit difficult to navigate. Additionally, both companies clearly outsource to the Philippines. I asked. While my conversations with the representatives in the Philippines was in English, it seemed like we were speaking different languages.

Canon on the other hand, routed me directly to a representative in Chesapeake, Virginia, told me the call was going to Chesapeake, Virginia and answered my questions as if we were actually having a conversation. I think this process is very telling…

A company who has little regard for the convenience of their consumers will outsource their support calls to off-shore call centers and sell you a printer with a print cartridge that is only 25% full. This company doesn’t recognizes the statement they make by outsourcing their support calls and manipulating consumers into a continuous buying cycle. This company doesn’t see that as a consumer, if I know a company is attempting to do right by me, I will continue to buy their products. Likewise, if I feel trapped into buying more and more from a company because I have no choice, I’ll be looking for a way out of business with them sooner than later.

Conversely, a company who keeps their support calls stateside and provides full-service at retail understands that consumer loyalty is based on providing 100% service, not manipulation. Canon is the winner in this case and my guess is that in every instance, Canon is going to fair better than both Lexmark and HP.

HP recently announced that they were laying off 8% of their workforce – 27,000 people. So my take-away from this experience: Hewlett-Packard doesn’t appear to care about the consumer or the worker. They appear to be the kind of company that is a bottom-line, profit-driven organization only – economy be damned.

My recommendation – Buy a Canon for your next printer purchase. I know I will…



Let There Be Light

I recently had to buy light bulbs. If you’re thinking that’s not really a topic for discussion, you haven’t bought light bulbs recently… Do you know the difference between Incandescent, Compact Fluorescent, LED and Halo...
by Communicado Magazine


Pickup & Delivery Service: WHAT!

So the Lincoln Motor Company has decided to introduce a new service called Lincoln Pickup & Delivery. Instead of explaining it, here’s what they posted on their website about this new “ownership experience:” An effor...
by Communicado Magazine

Do Not Enter

The Travel Ban

So we’ve had a new President for approximately two weeks and we already have our first controversy – The U.S. travel ban. It’s an executive order put in place by President Trump restricting entry to the United States ...
by Communicado Magazine



What have we done to our Election Process…

You should probably sit down… This is gonna take a minute… Originally, I said I wanted to start writing about Election 2016 at the beginning of 2016 because our general election cycles have started running together – ...
by Communicado Magazine


Five Guys or Shake Shack?

I do love a good burger. But, as Americans, I think that’s a requirement. I recently wrote a post about a gourmet burger I had at an upscale restaurant in lower Manhattan. It was a $25 burger… Don’t get me wrong, it was g...
by Communicado Magazine



So, the United Kingdom has decided they do not want to be a part of the European Union. They want to be their own sovereignty. Is anyone shocked by this? We’re talking about a nation that still has a royal family that is ...
by Communicado Magazine



  1. rmaslikhov

    This is very interesting. I was planning on purchasing an HP with AirPrint to effortlessly sync with all of my Apple products, and Canon was not in the picture because they do not offer a printer product with AirPrint,or so I thought. It appears that Canon offers AirPrint in their Pixma all-in-one printers, so I will definitely be giving this product line a closer look!

    Stay on it Communicado Magazine!

    Report this comment

You must be logged in to post a comment.